Tree persons 102708489422 (Elijah) and 102708489442 (Sarah) in tree 206849982. There are no master records yet (people/H0046.md and people/H0049.md do not exist). WikiTree Wilson-127402 ("Eligha D Wilson") and Chandler-14705 ("Sarah Ellen (Chandler) Phillips"). FamilySearch KZYV-GSZ and KJHW-8F1. Find a Grave 76413940 and 185825909.
These are the pending hints for both, plus targeted finds for the main gaps. Everything was viewed on screen. Nothing was saved, accepted, ignored or changed on Ancestry, Newspapers.com, Find a Grave, FamilySearch or WikiTree, and nothing was clipped. Sarah's Missouri death certificate, a free public record, was viewed in the browser's PDF viewer from the Missouri State Archives and was not saved. Readings in [brackets] are editorial. Records already abstracted in sources/ancestry/H0056-H0057-survey-abstracts.md are cited there and not repeated: the 1900 Elk River household (7602/29919099–101, image read) and James's Washington death certificate and indexes.
Spellings met: Elijah Daniel Wilson (tree), E. D. Wilson (1881 licence), Eiga/Eiza (1870), Elija D./Elisa D. (1880), Eligo/Eliga D. (1900), Lige (1910, 1912 notice), Eligha D. (Find a Grave, headstone "ELIGHA D. WILSON"), Eligah (SSACI). Sarah E. / S.E. Chandler (1870, 1880), Ella Chandler (1881), Sarah E. (1900), Ella Wilson (1910, 1920, 1927), Sarah Ellen Phillips (1937 certificate, Find a Grave).
H0046 Elijah Daniel Wilson
Facts on Ancestry as found (before any change)
| Fact | Value | Sources on the fact |
|---|
| Name | Elijah Daniel Wilson | – |
| Gender | Male | – |
| Birth | 25 Apr 1861 · Arkansas, USA | 0 |
| Death | 02 Dec 1912 · Noel, McDonald, Missouri, USA | 0 |
- The person has no sources at all. There are no marriage, residence, burial or occupation facts.
- Family in the tree: spouse Sarah Ellen 'Ella' Chandler; one child only, James Israel Wilson. Nancy, William Alfred, Mattie and Bertha are missing. No parents. Ancestry offers "potential" parents from "Shared DNA Origins": Richard Alfred Wilson and Martha Elam Tide Tyde Wilson. These are suggestions, not tree people.
- The timeline shows a "Possible marriage records" prompt.
- Hint counts: 15 new, 0 undecided, 0 ignored, 0 accepted.
Pending hints (15)
| # | Hint | Collection / record | Call |
|---|
| 0 | 1900 census: Eliga D Wilson | 7602/29919099 (image 4118801_00110) | Accept (image read, H0056 survey) |
| 1 | 1880 census: Elisa D. Wilson, Ball, Benton, Ark. | 6742/39574778; image 4239799-00679 | Accept (image read). Add the parents first |
| 2 | Find a Grave index: Eligha D Wilson | 60525/31444926 (memorial 76413940) | Accept |
| 3 | Member tree "Edwards_06-Feb-2012": Elijah Daniel WILSON | tree 179508080 / person 242330235293 | Ignore (member tree; leads) |
| 4 | Story "About Claud Alfred Wilson" (SmithPost2008) | tree 8475771 / person 232358538716, media 7a1bc4d2-7791-458c-9e67-58d5ca49e8c0 | Ignore (about a nephew; lead) |
| 5 | Member photo "ELIJAH D. WILSON stone" (nelsoki2003) | tree 71023345 / person 40234165746, media 08b858d2-fe7b-4f93-b299-e172a6b0e7f9 | Accept (his headstone) |
| 6 | Member photo "ELIJAH D. WILSON stone 1" (nelsoki2003) | media 88990694-360e-4cdd-bece-858440b35162 | Accept (not opened; check it is the same stone at apply) |
| 7 | Member photo "WILSON, ELIJAH DANIEL obit" (nelsoki2003) | media c353b6b8-7297-4aa6-9cbc-b91e66d50bb7 | Accept (death notices; checked against the newspaper page) |
| 8 | 1910 census: Lige Wilson, Elk River | 7884/14621689; image 31111_4330744-00128 | Accept (image read) |
| 9 | Web: McDonald County, Mo., Obituary Index: Elijah Wilson | 70537/43809 | Accept (index). Don't take "Burial Noel" |
| 10 | SSACI: Eligah Wilson (father on Mattie Wilson Adcock's claim) | 60901/609374223 (child's line 9374223) | Accept (parent name only) |
| 11 | Washington Select Death Index: Elijah Wilson (father of James) | 60229/1968433 | Accept (parent name only). Untick birthplace |
| 12 | Washington Death Records 1907–2017: Elijah Wilson (father of James) | 6716/112223031; image i2284759-01235 | Accept (parent name only). Untick birthplace "McDonall Co Missouri" |
| 13 | Arkansas County Marriages Index: E D Wilson | 2548/58466 | Accept (licence image read on FamilySearch) |
| 14 | U.S. City Directories: Elijah Wilson, Nashville, Tenn., 1882 | 2469/850291647 | Ignore (wrong person) |
Hint 0: 1900 census, STRONG (image read in the H0056 survey)
- 7602/29919099. Elk River Twp., McDonald Co., Mo.; ED 94; sheet 5; dwelling 88/98, family 98. Eligo [Eliga] D. Wilson, head, b. Apr 1861, 39, married 18 years, b. Arkansas, parents b. Tennessee; farmer; rents. With his wife Sarah E., five children and "Robert Chadler", brother-in-law, 43. The full abstract is in
H0056-H0057-survey-abstracts.md, Hint 5.
Hint 1: 1880 census, parents' household, STRONG (image read)
- 6742/39574778; image 4239799-00679 (image 17 of 21). Arkansas, Benton Co., Ball Twp.; roll 38; p. 336A [stamped 336]; ED 009; enumerated 8 [reading] June 1880; dwelling 150, family 160.
- Richard S. Wilson [reading: "Richard S"; the FamilySearch tree says Richard Alfred], head, W M, 48 [index], farming, b. Tennessee, parents b. Tennessee.
- Martha Wilson, wife, 43 [index], keeping house, b. Tennessee, parents b. South Carolina. There is an entry in the sickness column that was not read.
- James A., son, 23, farm labor, b. Arkansas, parents b. Tennessee.
- Elija D. [index "Elisa D."], son, 19, farm labor, b. Arkansas, parents b. Tennessee; attended school; cannot write [index].
- Richard A., son, 15, farm labor, b. Arkansas.
- Identity: the name Elija D., age 19 (b. 1861), Arkansas birth, Tennessee-born parents (the same answer he gave in 1900 and 1910) and Benton Co. (where he married a year later) all fit. This is the record that names his parents. Add Richard and Martha as parents before accepting; the panel has no "not a match" for parents.
Hint 2: Find a Grave index, STRONG
- 60525/31444926. Eligha D Wilson; b. 25 Apr 1861; d. 2 Dec 1912; Butler Creek Cemetery, Sulphur Springs, Benton Co., Arkansas; no biography; spouse Sarah Ellen Phillips; children William Alfred Wilson, Martha June Adcock, James Israel Wilson.
- Memorial 76413940 (read only): created by "Laura" on 12 Sep 2011 and maintained by Kathy S. It has 2 photos added by Carolyn Hartsell on 2 Apr 2015. Linked: spouse Sarah Ellen Chandler Phillips (1863–1937); children James Israel (1882–1941), William Alfred (1886–1972) and Martha June "Mattie" Wilson Adcock (1889–1960).
- Headstone (photo read): "ELIGHA D. WILSON / BORN / APR 25 1861 / DIED / DEC 2 1912". An upright tablet.
- Identity: the exact dates, his wife and three children. At apply, "Sarah Ellen Phillips" is the existing Sarah (her later married name). The burial place is Sulphur Springs, Ark., not Noel.
Hint 3: Member tree "Edwards_06-Feb-2012", IGNORE (member tree)
- Claims: alternate birth 21 Apr 1861, Arkansas; Residence 1870 Flint, Benton, Ark., post office Hico (verified below); 1880 Ball Twp; marriage 21 Jul 1881 Benton Co. to Sarah Ellen Chandler; 1882 Nashville (wrong, from hint 14); death 2 Dec 1912 Noel; burial "Noel, Missouri" (from the obituary index). Parents Richard Alfred WILSON Sr (1834–1914) and Martha E. 'Tide' WILSON (1838–1890); the tree says Martha died in 1890 in Tennessee. Brother Richard Alfred WILSON II (b. 19 May 1865, Ark., d. 1943). Children James Israel (1882), Roxie Anna (b. 3 Feb 1884, Robinson, Benton, Ark., d. 1957), William Alfred (1886), Mattie/Martha June Adcock (1889–1960) (entered twice), Burtha (b. Sep 1891, Ark.).
Hint 4: Story "About Claud Alfred Wilson", IGNORE (about a nephew), lead
- Typed extract credited to "Wilson Chronicles" by Dorothy Ware Wilson, 1989 (a family compilation), shared by James Smith on 17 Feb 2022. It is linked to Eliga D Lige Wilson, William Arch Wilson, Claud Alfred Wilson, James Oliver "Ollie" Wilson and Mary Almina Estell.
- Claims (paraphrase): Claude Alfred Wilson, b. 3 Nov 1881 at Robinson, Ark., eldest son of William Arch Wilson. He and his brother Ollie rode to Noel, Mo. to visit their father's brother "Lige" Wilson and family, then to Anderson, Mo., to visit their mother's sister Elmina Van Winkle. They later carried the mail for their uncle Richard Wilson between Springdale and Huntsville. Claud died of pneumonia on 12 Jan 1901, aged 19, and was buried at Yell Cemetery, Robinson.
- Value: this places Lige's family at Noel c.1899–1900 and names two brothers, William Arch and Richard. William fits the 1870 son William, 11; Richard fits Richard A., 15, in 1880. A derivative family history; lead only.
Hints 5–6: Member photos of the headstone, ACCEPT (grave)
- Hint 5 (viewed): the same upright stone as Carolyn Hartsell's Find a Grave photo. The uploader's description reads "From findagrave". Ancestry keeps the attribution; note that the original photographer is Carolyn Hartsell (Find a Grave, 2 Apr 2015).
- Hint 6 ("stone 1") was not opened. It has the same uploader and title and is probably the close-up of the inscription. Glance at it before accepting.
Hint 7: Member photo "WILSON, ELIJAH DANIEL obit", ACCEPT (document), checked against the original
- The image is a McDonald County library obituary-file sheet, typed heading "Wilson, Elijah / Pineville Hearld [sic] / Dec. 2, 1912". Two clippings are pasted on it, each hand-dated "Dec. 2, 1912 P.H." [the death date, not the issue date]. This is a derivative copy made by the library and uploaded by nelsoki2003 on 24 Apr 2017.
- Original: The Pineville Herald, Pineville, Mo., Friday 6 December 1912, p. 1, "County Correspondence" (Newspapers.com image 580726658, State Historical Society of Missouri). Found by one targeted search for "Lige Wilson", 2–31 Dec 1912 (1 hit). Page viewed, not clipped. Both items are on this page:
- "Noel." column: "Elijah Wilson, who has been ill some time of consumption, passed away at 4 o'clock Monday morning."
- "Butler Creek." column: "Died, at his home near Butler Creek, Monday morning at about 2 o'clock, December 2, 1912, Lige Wilson. He leaves a host of friends and relatives to mourn his death."
- Findings: he died on Monday 2 Dec 1912 at his home near Butler Creek, of consumption [tuberculosis], after a long illness. The two correspondents give different hours (4 and about 2 a.m.). Transcribe into
sources/ancestry/H0046-member-media.md at apply.
Hint 8: 1910 census, STRONG (image read)
- 7884/14621689 (Lige) and 7884/185915694 (Ella). Missouri, McDonald Co., Elk River Twp.; ED 0110; sheet 2B; roll T624_797; FHL 1374810; image 31111_4330744-00128 (image 4 of 18). Dwelling 49, family 49.
- Lige Wilson, head, M W 48, first marriage, married 28 years, b. Arkansas, father b. Tennessee, mother b. Tennessee; farmer, home farm, own account; rents, farm; reads and writes.
- Ella, wife, F W 47, first marriage, 28 years, children born 3, living 3 [image reading "3 3"; index 3/3; the 1900 census said 5/5], b. Missouri, parents b. Missouri.
- Mattie, dau., F W 21, single, b. Arkansas, father b. Arkansas, mother b. Missouri.
- James Chandler, brother-in-law, M W 53, single, b. Missouri, parents b. Missouri. This is the "Robert Chadler", 43, of 1900: Robert James Chandler, b. c.1857.
- Next dwelling (50): Claude Gatton, head, 26, with wife Bertha and a child [not transcribed]. This is the daughter Bertha Ellen's household (see the 1920 census).
- Identity: name, age, Arkansas birth, Tennessee-born parents, wife Ella, daughter Mattie and the Chandler brother-in-law all fit.
Hint 9: McDonald County Obituary Index, STRONG (index)
- 70537/43809. Elijah Wilson; death 2 Dec 1912; "Burial Place: Noel, Missouri" [index field, contradicted by the grave]; publication Pineville Herald; source web page librarymail.org/genehist/obits (McDonald County Library). This indexes the clippings in hint 7.
Hint 10: SSACI, Mattie's claim, STRONG (parent name only)
- 60901/609374223 (Eligah as father); child's line 60901/9374223: Mattie Wilson Adcock [also "Mattie Wilson Wilson"], female, white, b. 14 Jan 1889, "Bintin" [Benton], Arkansas; father Eligah Wilson; mother Ella Chandler; SSN 513-16-6412 [a Kansas-issued number]; note "Jul 1941: name listed as Mattie Wilson Adcock".
- Identity: Mattie's birth (1900: Jun 1889 [reading]; tree of Find a Grave: 1889) and both parents' names. It supports only the parents' names and Mattie's birth, which places the family in Benton Co. in Jan 1889.
Hints 11–12: Washington death indexes and certificate for James, STRONG (parent name only)
- 60229/1968433 and 6716/112223031 (image i2284759-01235) are James Israel Wilson's 1941 certificate no. 248, with father Elijah Wilson, b. "McDonald Co. Missouri". The informant was James's second wife. The birthplace is wrong for Elijah (Arkansas in four censuses). See
H0056-H0057-survey-abstracts.md, Hints 2 and 6. Accept for the father–son link only and untick the birthplace.
Hint 13: Arkansas County Marriages, STRONG (original read on FamilySearch)
- Ancestry 2548/58466 (groom) and 2548/2130918 (bride): E D Wilson, age 20, b. 1861; Ella Chandler, age 18, b. 1863; licence 20 Jul 1881; marriage 21 Jul 1881, Benton Co., Arkansas; FHL film 1034661.
- Original read (FamilySearch "Arkansas, County Marriages, 1837–1957", DGS 004401666, image 101 of 659, image ARK 3:1:S3HT-D1S7-J1H; index ARKs 1:1:N9QV-YQ2 [groom] and 1:1:N9QV-YQK). Benton Co. marriage record, p. 190, first entry:
- Licence, State of Arkansas, County of Benton: "…solemnize the rites and publish the bans of Matrimony, between E. D. Wilson aged 20 years, and Ella Chandler aged 18 years…". Witness my hand and official seal, 20 July 1881, John Black, Clerk.
- Certificate: "I, J. S. McIntyre do hereby certify, that on the 21 day of July A.D. 1881, I did duly… solemnize the rite and publish the bans of Matrimony between the parties…". Witness my hand 21 July 1881, J. S. McIntyre, J.P.
- Recorded and filed 28 July 1881, John Black, Clerk.
- This is the primary record of the marriage. The ages fit births in 1861 and 1863. Save it to Sarah too.
Hint 14: Nashville City Directory 1882, IGNORE (wrong person)
- 2469/850291647. AI-extracted: Elijah Wilson, "works", Nashville, Tenn., 1882. Nothing identifies him. Ours married in Benton Co. in Jul 1881, and his children were born in Arkansas in 1882 and 1884.
Target gaps (Elijah)
1870 census, parents' household, FOUND (not a hint), image read
- 7163/13494716 (Elijah, index "Eiza"); head 7163/12568106. Arkansas, Benton Co., Flint Twp., post office Hico; roll M593_47; p. 233B; image 4259242_00461 (image 26 of 43). Dwelling 175, family 180 [reading].
- Richard Wilson, 36, M W, farmer, real estate $400, personal $200, b. Tennessee.
- Martha, 34, F W, keeping house, b. Tennessee.
- James, 12; William, 11; "Eiga" [Eliga; index "Eiza"], 9, M; Richard, 7; all b. Arkansas.
- Identity: fits 1880 (Richard and Martha b. Tennessee; James, Elija D. and Richard A.) and the story's brothers William and Richard.
- Ancestry also suggests for Richard: 1860 census 7667/12858297; 1880 own line 6742/6059159; Find a Grave "Richard Alfred Wilson" 60525/29767870 (not viewed; for a parents' pass).
Death: Missouri death certificate, NOT FOUND
- Missouri State Archives, Death Certificates 1910–1975 (s1.sos.mo.gov): surname Wilson, McDonald Co., 1912–1913 returned only Solomon Banjamin [Benjamin] Wilson, d. 14 Mar 1912, cert. 10053-a (not ours). Surname Wilson, all counties, Nov–Dec 1912 returned 25 names and no Elijah, Lige, Eliga or E. D.
- Reading: he died "at his home near Butler Creek" (Pineville Herald). Either the death went unregistered in Missouri, or the home was across the line in Benton Co., Ark. (Butler Creek Cemetery is at Sulphur Springs, Ark.). Arkansas had no statewide death registration until 1914. The tree's "Noel, McDonald, Missouri" is the post-office town of the news column, not a proven death place.
Burial
- Butler Creek Cemetery, Sulphur Springs, Benton Co., Ark.: Find a Grave memorial 76413940 with a headstone photo. Sarah was buried there in 1937 (her death certificate says "Sulphur Springs, Ark."), and Find a Grave has her memorial 185825909 in the same cemetery, without a photo. No burial date.
Residences by decade (Elijah)
| Year | Place | Record |
|---|
| 1861 | born Arkansas [FS: Benton Co.] | censuses 1870–1910 |
| 1870 | Flint Twp., Benton Co., Ark. (PO Hico), with his parents | 7163/13494716 |
| 1880 | Ball Twp., Benton Co., Ark., with his parents; farm labourer | 6742/39574778 |
| 1881 | married at Benton Co., Ark. | Benton Co. marriage record p. 190 |
| 1882–1889 | Arkansas; the children born in Arkansas; Robinson, Benton Co. (member tree), "Bintin" Ark. (Mattie's SSACI) | 1900 image; 60901/9374223 |
| c.1890–91 | moved to McDonald Co., Mo. (Bertha b. Sep 1891, Pineville per member tree) | lead |
| 1900 | Elk River Twp., McDonald Co., Mo.; farmer, renting | 7602/29919099 |
| c.1900 | "Lige Wilson and family" at Noel (Wilson Chronicles) | story (lead) |
| 1910 | Elk River Twp., McDonald Co.; farmer, renting | 7884/14621689 |
| 1912 | died at his home near Butler Creek, 2 Dec 1912, of consumption | Pineville Herald, 6 Dec 1912, p. 1 |
- WikiTree Wilson-127402 (API read only): "Eligha D Wilson", b. 25 Apr 1861, d. 2 Dec 1912 "Arkansas"; no parents; unmanaged. Spouse Chandler-14705, with marriage "1881" (guessed). Their son William Alfred Wilson-127401 (b. 2 Mar 1886 Robinson, Benton, Ark., d. 5 Apr 1972 Noel) is linked. James Wilson-127909 is not linked to them.
- FamilySearch KZYV-GSZ (read only): birth 25 Apr 1861 Benton, Arkansas; death 2 Dec 1912 Noel; burial Butler Creek Cemetery, Sulphur Springs; residences 1870 Flint, 1880 Ball Twp, 1900 Elk River. Parents Richard Alfred Wilson (1834–1914) LHJP-DWK and Martha Elam Wilson (1836–1890) LHJP-TC2, married 1855 "Benton, Saline, Arkansas" [FS standardization; check]. Siblings James Martin (1856–1906) G3C3-7XF, William (1859–) L28X-NRC, Richard A. (1865–1943) LHJP-T99.
H0049 Sarah Ellen "Ella" Chandler
Facts on Ancestry as found (before any change)
| Fact | Value | Sources on the fact |
|---|
| Name | Sarah Ellen 'Ella' Chandler | – |
| Gender | Female | – |
| Birth | 4 Mar 1863 · Crawford County, Missouri, USA | 0 |
| Death | 6 Jan 1937 · West Dolan Township, Cass, Missouri, USA | 0 |
- No sources. There are no marriage, residence or burial facts, and no second husband. Ancestry offers a "potential father" (Shared DNA Origins), John CHANDLER Jr.; there is no mother.
- Family in the tree: spouse Elijah; child James only.
- Hint counts: 11 new, 0 undecided, 0 ignored, 0 accepted.
Pending hints (11)
| # | Hint | Collection / record | Call |
|---|
| 0 | Find a Grave index: Sarah Ellen Phillips | 60525/149858176 (memorial 185825909) | Accept |
| 1 | Member tree "Curb Family Tree": Sarah Ellen Chandler | (compare page; ids not captured) | Ignore (member tree) |
| 2 | 1900 census: Sarah E Wilson | 7602/29919100 | Accept (image read, H0056 survey) |
| 3 | 1880 census: S.e. Chandler, Joplin, Jasper, Mo. | 6742/34040801; image 4241896-00258 | Accept (index) |
| 4 | 1920 census: Ella Wilson, Gravette, Benton, Ark. | 6061/108765080; image 4294350-00738 | Accept (index) |
| 5 | Arkansas County Marriages Index: Ella Chandler | 2548/2130918 | Accept (original read; see Elijah hint 13) |
| 6 | Washington Death Records: Sarah Chandler (mother of James) | 6716/127223031 | Accept (mother's name only). Untick birthplace |
| 7 | Washington Select Death Index: Sarah Chandler (mother of James) | 60229/1968434 | Accept (mother's name only) |
| 8 | 1870 census: Sarah E Chandler, Osage, Crawford, Mo. | 7163/5039326; image 4273247_00720 | Accept (image read) |
| 9 | 1910 census: Ella Wilson, Elk River | 7884/185915694 | Accept (image read; see Elijah hint 8) |
| 10 | SSACI: Ella Chandler (mother on Mattie Wilson Adcock's claim) | 60901/759374223 (child's line 9374223) | Accept (mother's name only) |
Hint 0: Find a Grave index, STRONG
- 60525/149858176. Sarah Ellen Phillips, maiden name Chandler; b. 4 Mar 1863, Crawford Co., Mo.; d. 6 Jan 1937, Cass Co., Mo.; Butler Creek Cemetery, Sulphur Springs, Benton Co., Ark.; has a biography; spouse Eligha D Wilson; children William Alfred Wilson, Martha June Adcock, James Israel Wilson.
- Memorial 185825909 (read only): "Sarah Ellen Chandler Phillips"; created by "Cinderella" on 10 Dec 2017 and maintained by Scot Stout; no photos. Bio: "daughter of John and Martha Jane (Whitehead) Chandler". Linked: spouse Eligha D Wilson; children James, William Alfred, Mattie. (Frank Phillips is not linked.)
- Identity: her exact dates, the birth county, both husbands' surnames and the children. At apply, keep "Phillips" as an alternate (married) name. There is no headstone photo, so the burial rests on the death certificate.
Hint 1: Member tree "Curb Family Tree", IGNORE (member tree)
- Card: b. 4 Mar 1863 Crawford, Mo.; d. 6 Jan 1937 "Westline, Cass, Mo." [West Line, a village in Cass Co.]; child James Israel entered twice. The West Line death place is a lead that fits West Dolan Twp.
Hint 2: 1900 census, STRONG
- 7602/29919100. Sarah E., wife, b. Mar 1863, 37, married 18 years, 5 children born, 5 living, b. Missouri, parents b. Missouri. See
H0056-H0057-survey-abstracts.md, Hint 5.
Hint 3: 1880 census, mother's household, STRONG (index only)
- 6742/34040801. Missouri, Jasper Co., Joplin; roll 695; p. 620B; ED 074; dwelling 98.
- M. J. Chandler, head, 48 [b. c.1832; = Martha Jane, "Jane", 38, in 1870].
- G., son, 25 [George, b. c.1855]; R. J., son, 23 [Robert James, b. c.1857]; W. H., son, 19 [William Henry, b. c.1861].
- S. E. Chandler, dau., 17, single, housekeeper, b. Missouri, father b. Missouri, mother b. Missouri; cannot write [index].
- Identity: her initials, age, the mother's initials, and the brothers from 1870 all fit. The household has no father, which fits his death before her birth. The image was not viewed.
Hint 4: 1920 census, widowed, with her daughter Bertha, STRONG (index)
- 6061/108765080. Arkansas, Benton Co., Gravette, Rocky Dell Road; roll T625_54; p. 13A; ED 34; image 4294350-00738 (not viewed).
- Household of Claud H. Gatton, head, 36; Bertha Gatton, wife, 28 [= Bertha Ellen Wilson, b. Sep 1891]; Richard 10, Cannen [Carmen?] 9, Cleo 8, Ross 6 and Julia 0 Gatton; and Ella Wilson [alt. "Walson"], mother-in-law, 55 [b. c.1865], widowed, b. Missouri, parents b. Missouri; reads and writes.
- Identity: Ella Wilson, widowed after 1912, living with the Gattons, who were her next-door neighbours in 1910. Her age is two years young.
Hint 5: Arkansas County Marriages Index, STRONG
- 2548/2130918: Ella Chandler, 18, b. 1863; licence 20 Jul 1881; married 21 Jul 1881, Benton Co., Ark.; spouse E D Wilson; FHL 1034661. The original is abstracted under Elijah, hint 13.
Hints 6–7: Washington death records for James, STRONG (mother's name only)
- 6716/127223031 and 60229/1968434 are James Israel Wilson's certificate no. 248: mother Sarah Chandler, b. "McDonald Co. Missour[i]" [wrong; she was born in Crawford Co.]. Accept for the mother–son link; untick the birthplace.
Hint 8: 1870 census, mother's household, STRONG (image read)
- 7163/5039326. Missouri, Crawford Co., Osage Twp., post office Cuba; roll M593_772; p. 670A; image 4273247_00720 (image 16 of 20). Dwelling 112, family 107 [image; the index says dwelling 107].
- Jane Chandler, 38, F W, housekeeper, real estate $400, personal $375, b. Missouri.
- Thomas, 18, M, farmer; James, 11, M; George, 14, M; William H., 8, M; Sarah E., 6, F; all b. Missouri.
- Identity: Sarah E., age 6 (b. c.1863–64), in Crawford Co. (her birthplace on the death certificate), with the brothers who appear with her in 1880 (George, R. J./James, W. H.). There is no husband: widow Jane = Martha Jane (Whitehead) Chandler.
Hint 9: 1910 census, STRONG
- 7884/185915694. See Elijah hint 8. Ella, 47, married 28 years, 3 born / 3 living [conflicts with 1900's 5/5], b. Missouri.
Hint 10: SSACI, Mattie's claim, STRONG (mother's name only)
- 60901/759374223 (Ella Chandler as mother); child's line 9374223. See Elijah hint 10.
Target gaps (Sarah)
Second marriage: Frank Phillips, 12 Apr 1927, Noel, Mo. (FOUND, not a hint; image read)
- Ancestry 1171/507240932 (Missouri, Marriage Records, 1805–2002: Ella Wilson; marriage 12 Apr 1927, Noel, McDonald, Mo.; spouse Frank Phillips). Image vrmmo1833_c15105-0350 (McDonald > Record Images for McDonald > 1918–1933, image 303 of 565). The upper licence on the left-hand page is p. 224.
- Marriage License, State of Missouri, County of McDonald: to marry Frank Phillips of Sulphur Springs, County of Benton, State of Arkansas, over the age of twenty-one years, and Ella Wilson of Noel, County of McDonald, State of Missouri, over the age of eighteen years. Witness the recorder of deeds, Pineville, 11 April 1927, R. L. [surname not read], Recorder of Deeds.
- Certificate: the undersigned Justice of the Peace did at Noel, Mo., on the 12th day of April 1927, unite in marriage the above named persons [J.P.'s signature not read with confidence]. Filed for record 13 Apr 1927.
- Identity: "Ella Wilson of Noel", widowed 1912 (1920 census). The groom is from Sulphur Springs, Ark., where her first husband lies buried. Her 1937 death certificate names her husband as Frank Phillips. Found by an Ancestry marriage search for Ella Wilson with spouse Frank Phillips.
- Frank Phillips's age, parents and death are unknown; he died before Jan 1937 (she was then a widow). FamilySearch has him as G2FV-6RP ("Deceased", no marriage event).
Death certificate: Missouri, 1937 (FOUND, image read; free public record)
- Missouri State Archives, Missouri Death Certificates 1910–1975: search Deceased "Phillips" + "Sarah", Cass Co. Two results: Sarah E. Phillips, 6 Jan 1937, Cass, certificate 538 (ours) and Sarah E. Phillips, 22 Nov 1937, Cass, cert. 40937 (a different woman; not viewed). Image URL sos.mo.gov/images/archives/deathcerts/1937/1937_00000538.PDF, 4 pages: the certificate, a blank back, a supplemental report and a blank back.
- Missouri State Board of Health, Bureau of Vital Statistics, Certificate of Death; file no. 538; registration district no. 160; primary registration district 2225 [reading]; received "FEB 16 1937" [stamp].
- Place of death: County Cass, Township West Dolan.
- Sarah Ellen Phillips; female; white; widow; husband Frank Phillips.
- Born March 4, 1863; age 73 y 10 m 2 d.
- Occupation housekeeper.
- Birthplace Crawford Co., Mo.
- Father John Chandler, birthplace unknown. Mother's maiden name Martha Jane Whitehead, birthplace unknown.
- Informant Alford [Alfred] Wilson, address Pittsburg, Kans. [her son William Alfred].
- Burial: Sulphur Springs, Ark.; date blank. Undertaker Geo. E. Myers [reading], Cleveland, Mo. [Cass Co.].
- Filed Jan 7, 1937, Mary Meador, registrar.
- Medical certificate: died Jan 6th, 1937. Attended Jan 4, 1937, to Jan 4, 1937, and last seen alive Jan 4. Death at 4:30 [a.m./p.m. not marked]. Cause intestinal obstruction and toxaemia; contributory gall bladder disease; no operation; no injury. Signed Dr. E. H. Owen [reading], Harrisonville, Mo.
- Supplemental report (PDF p. 3; stamped "SUPPLEMENTAL" [reading]): Sarah Ellen Phillips, West Dolan, Cass; 73 y 10 m 2 d; d. Jan 6, 1937; contributory causes "Gall bladder disease / Malignancy"; signed E. H. Owen, Harrisonville; filed Jan 7, 1937, Mary Meador.
- This is the only record naming her parents, apart from Find a Grave's bio, which copies it. The informant is her son. Her father's name agrees with Ancestry's suggested "John Chandler Jr.", and her mother's with the 1870 census ("Jane") and 1880 census ("M. J.").
Burial
- Sulphur Springs, Ark. (death certificate) = Butler Creek Cemetery, beside or near Elijah (Find a Grave 185825909, no photo). No burial date.
1930 census, NOT FOUND
- Ancestry 6224: Ella Phillips b. 1863 ±3 (all places, also filtered to Ark./Mo./Kans./Okla.); Frank Phillips with spouse Ella (5,080 results; none in Benton/McDonald/Cass); Sarah Phillips b. 1863 ±2. No candidate.
- FamilySearch 1930 (collection 1810731): surname Phillips, b. 1861–65 Missouri, spouse's given name Frank (162 results). The only one near her 1937 home is "F W Phillips", b. c.1864 Missouri, Harrisonville, Cass Co. (household not opened). This is a possible lead for Frank; unverified.
Obituary, NOT FOUND
- Newspapers.com, two targeted searches, 6–31 Jan 1937: Phillips + "Sulphur Springs" (815 hits, no Cass Co. or McDonald Co. paper on the first page); "Mrs. Frank Phillips", Missouri (8 hits: Princeton, Clarence, Macon, Nevada and Kansas City papers, none about her).
Residences by decade (Sarah)
| Year | Place | Record |
|---|
| 1863 | born 4 Mar 1863, Crawford Co., Mo., after her father's death | death certificate 538 |
| 1870 | Osage Twp., Crawford Co., Mo. (PO Cuba), with her widowed mother Jane | 7163/5039326 |
| 1880 | Joplin, Jasper Co., Mo., with her mother M. J. and brothers | 6742/34040801 |
| 1881 | married E. D. Wilson, Benton Co., Ark., 21 Jul 1881 | Benton Co. marriage record p. 190 |
| 1882–1889 | Benton Co., Ark. (children's births) | 1900 image; 60901/9374223 |
| 1900 | Elk River Twp., McDonald Co., Mo. | 7602/29919100 |
| 1910 | Elk River Twp., McDonald Co., Mo. | 7884/185915694 |
| 1912 | widowed 2 Dec 1912 | Pineville Herald |
| 1920 | Rocky Dell Road, Gravette, Benton Co., Ark., with daughter Bertha Gatton | 6061/108765080 |
| 1927 | "of Noel"; married Frank Phillips at Noel, 12 Apr 1927 | 1171/507240932 |
| 1930 | not found | – |
| 1937 | died a widow, West Dolan Twp., Cass Co., Mo., 6 Jan 1937; buried Sulphur Springs, Ark. | Mo. death cert. 538 |
- WikiTree Chandler-14705 (API read only): Sarah Ellen (Chandler) Phillips, b. 4 Mar 1863 Crawford, Mo.; d. 6 Jan 1937 Cass, Mo.; no parents; unmanaged; spouse Wilson-127402; child Wilson-127401.
- FamilySearch KJHW-8F1 (read only): b. 4 Mar 1863 Osage Township, Crawford, Mo.; d. 6 Jan 1937 Cass; burial Butler Creek Cemetery. Brief life history: "Sarah Ann Chandler Wilson Phillips was born 4 March 1863, 5 months after her father died. Called Ella." 16 sources: 1870, 1880, the 1881 marriage (several), 1900, 1920 and James's Washington death records; no 1910, 1930 or 1937 death certificate. Spouses: Elijah (m. 21 Jul 1881, Benton, Ark.) and Frank Phillips G2FV-6RP (no marriage event). Parents John Chandler Jr (1831–1862) KJHW-87M and Martha Jane Whitehead (1831–1890) GW3F-ZVN, married 17 Oct 1850, Osage Twp., Crawford, Mo. Siblings: John Thomas (1851–1941) KJHW-841, Mary Elizabeth (1854–1888) KJHW-88W, George C. (1855–1925) KJHW-8DP, Robert 'James' (1857–1935) KJHW-86S, Samuel A (1859–1870) KJD2-BRM, Eliza J. (1859–) KJD2-1DQ, William Henry (1861–1931) KJHW-8F4.
Children (five), all born 1882–1891; none living
1900: 5 born, 5 living (Sarah's own line). None later than Bertha (1891).
| # | Child | Records seen (ids) | IDs and notes |
|---|
| 1 | James Israel Wilson, b. 14 Jun 1882, Ark.; d. 8 Dec 1941 Aberdeen, Wash. | 1900 7602/29919101 | Tree 102706145688 (H0056); FS L2Z7-VRM; WikiTree Wilson-127909 (not linked to parents) |
| 2 | Nancy Roxy Anna ("Nancy R." 1900; "Roxie Anna"), b. Feb 1884, Ark. [3 Feb 1884, Robinson, Benton Co., member trees]; d. 1957 | 1900 (line not captured) | Not in the Ancestry tree. FS LCPT-KG8 |
| 3 | William Alfred ("Wm A." 1900; "Alford Wilson" 1937), b. Mar 1886, Ark. [2 Mar 1886, Robinson, Benton Co.]; d. 5 Apr 1972 Noel (WikiTree) | 1900; informant on his mother's 1937 certificate, living at Pittsburg, Kans. | Not in the Ancestry tree. FS 98GP-RQN; WikiTree Wilson-127401; Find a Grave linked to Elijah's memorial |
| 4 | Martha June/Jane "Mattie", b. 14 Jan 1889, "Bintin" [Benton], Ark.; m. Adcock; d. 1960 | 1900; 1910 (21, single, at home) 7884 same household; SSACI 60901/9374223 | Not in the Ancestry tree. FS 98GP-RQJ; Find a Grave "Martha June 'Mattie' Wilson Adcock" |
| 5 | Bertha Ellen ("Burtha" 1900), b. Sep 1891 [Pineville, McDonald Co., member tree]; m. Claud H. Gatton c.1909; d. 1969 | 1900; 1910 next door as Bertha Gatton (dwelling 50); 1920 Gravette, Ark. (6061/108765080 household) | Not in the Ancestry tree. FS L4TK-Q5S |
Conflicts
- Elijah's death place. Tree: Noel, McDonald Co., Mo. Pineville Herald: "at his home near Butler Creek" (in the Butler Creek correspondence column); the Noel column also reports it. WikiTree: "Arkansas". No Missouri death certificate exists (statewide search). Keep "near Butler Creek" with the state unproven; Noel is the news-column town.
- Elijah's burial. Butler Creek Cemetery, Sulphur Springs, Benton Co., Ark. (Find a Grave with a headstone photo; Sarah's burial there in 1937) against "Noel, Missouri" (McDonald Co. obituary index field; the Edwards member tree). Take Sulphur Springs.
- Hour of death: 4 a.m. (Noel column) against about 2 a.m. (Butler Creek column).
- Elijah's birthplace: Arkansas (1870, 1880, 1900, 1910) against "McDonald Co., Missouri" (James's 1941 certificate; informant a wife of four months). The county in Arkansas is unproven: FamilySearch says Benton Co.; his parents were in Benton Co. by 1870.
- Elijah's father's middle name: "Richard S." (1880 index and image reading) against "Richard Alfred" (FamilySearch, member tree, Find a Grave index suggestion). Martha's age: 34 (1870) against 43 (1880 index). Richard's: 36 (1870) against 48 (1880).
- Year of marriage: 21 Jul 1881 (licence and return) against "married 18 years" in 1900 and "28 years" in 1910 (both pointing to c.1882). The licence governs.
- Sarah's children: 5 born / 5 living (1900) against 3 / 3 (1910 image reading). Five children are known by name. The 1910 figure is probably an error.
- Sarah's given name: Sarah Ellen (death certificate; Find a Grave; tree) and "Ella" (1881, 1910, 1920, 1927) against FamilySearch's life sketch "Sarah Ann" (unsourced).
- Sarah's age in 1920: 55 (b. c.1865) against 4 Mar 1863.
- Sarah's birthplace: Crawford Co., Mo. (death certificate; 1870 residence) against "McDonald Co. Missouri" (James's certificate). FamilySearch refines it to Osage Twp., Crawford Co. (the 1870 residence).
- Her brother in the household: "Robert Chadler", 43 (1900) and "James Chandler", 53 (1910) are one man, Robert James Chandler ("R. J.", 23, in 1880; FS KJHW-86S, 1857–1935). The ages disagree (b. c.1857 in 1900; c.1857 in 1910).
- Sarah's father's death: FamilySearch gives 1862, "5 months" before her birth. The 1870 census shows the mother as head without a husband; the certificate gives only his name. The death date is unverified.
- The FamilySearch marriage place of Elijah's parents ("1855, Benton, Saline, Arkansas") looks like a standardization error for Benton Co. Unverified.
Gaps
- Elijah's death record: none in Missouri. Look for Benton Co., Ark. records (none statewide before 1914), and for a McDonald Co. or Benton Co. probate or guardianship.
- The 1890s move from Benton Co., Ark., to McDonald Co., Mo. (c.1890–91), and the family at Noel c.1900 (Wilson Chronicles).
- Sarah, 1913–1936: 1930 census not found; Frank Phillips's identity, age, death and burial (before Jan 1937); how she came to be in West Dolan Twp., Cass Co. (a child living there?).
- Obituaries: Elijah's two death notices were found (Pineville Herald, 6 Dec 1912). No obituary for Sarah was found in two targeted Newspapers.com searches. Cass Co. papers (Harrisonville) and the Gravette, Ark., papers for Jan 1937 are the next places to look.
- Parents' passes: Richard (S./Alfred) Wilson and Martha, Tennessee-born, of Flint and Ball Twps., Benton Co., Ark.; John Chandler and Martha Jane Whitehead of Crawford Co., Mo. (m. 17 Oct 1850 per FamilySearch; unverified).
- The 1880 image of the Chandler household (Joplin) and the 1920 Gatton image were not viewed.
- Member photo hint 6 ("stone 1") was not opened.
Leads
- Elijah's siblings: James A./James Martin (b. c.1857–58, d. 1906), William Arch (b. c.1859; of Robinson, Ark.; wife Mary Almina Estell; sons Claud Alfred, 1881–1901, and James Oliver "Ollie"), Richard A. (Alfred) Jr. (b. 19 May 1865, d. 1943; a mail contractor, Springdale–Huntsville, c.1900). Source: Dorothy Ware Wilson, Wilson Chronicles (1989), via the Ancestry story in tree 8475771.
- Richard Alfred Wilson Sr (1834–1914): Ancestry suggests an 1860 census (7667/12858297), his own 1880 line (6742/6059159) and a Find a Grave memorial (60525/29767870).
- Martha (Elam?) "Tide" Wilson, 1836/38–1890; the member tree says she died in Tennessee.
- Frank Phillips of Sulphur Springs, Benton Co., Ark. (1927). Possibly "F W Phillips", b. c.1864 Mo., Harrisonville, Cass Co., 1930 (FamilySearch index; unverified). FS G2FV-6RP.
- Claud H. Gatton (b. c.1884) and Bertha Ellen Wilson: Gravette, Ark., 1920; McDonald Co. 1910.
- William Alfred Wilson at Pittsburg, Kans. (1937); Mattie Adcock's Kansas Social Security number (513-).
- Sarah E. Phillips, d. 22 Nov 1937, Cass Co., cert. 40937: a different woman of the same name in the same county. Don't confuse them.
Blockers
- None. One tab (1013502130). About 130 browser steps. When clicked, the Missouri State Archives "View Image" link opened a second tab; I closed it at once and read the PDF in my own tab. Missouri death-certificate searches need a real click on "Search"; a form submitted by script returns "no records".